Reading Log #1
In the beginning of the novel, The Good Lord Bird, Old John Brown a strong abolitionist frees Henry from Dutch's Tavern. When they first talked John Brown already felt connected to Henry and was giving him symbolic items, such as his good luck onion, his daughters dress and bonnet, and a feather from a good lord bird. When Henry got the onion he didn't understand why John Brown gave it to him, so he ate it. John Brown then decided to call him Onion, and looked at him as his good luck charm. As Henry got to know Fredrick, one of John Brown's sons they talked about the good lord bird. Fredrick told Henry that a feather from the good lord bird can give a man wisdom. John Brown never gave any of his sons a feather from the good lord bird so it represents how John Brown feels about Henry and how close he feels they are. It connects with the title because the feather of the good lord bird was given to Henry when him and John Brown first met, and with the title being "The Good Lord Bird" I feel like it shows that that started the long relationship between Henry and John Brown.
Henry's rationale for lying was to keep him safe. When he started the lie John Brown thought he was a girl when he misunderstood his name for Henrietta and gave him a dress and a bonnet. They started to get to know each other but Henry felt more safe to keep it a secret. Onion felt his life was a lot easier being a girl too, instead of having the expectation of fighting in the wars to come, he would avoid them by continuing his lie about his gender. I believe it is justifiable because it made his life easier and it kept him out of situations that could put his life in danger. For example when he was in Pikesville, he would have been put in the pen, and have a higher chance of dying.
Henry's rationale for lying was to keep him safe. When he started the lie John Brown thought he was a girl when he misunderstood his name for Henrietta and gave him a dress and a bonnet. They started to get to know each other but Henry felt more safe to keep it a secret. Onion felt his life was a lot easier being a girl too, instead of having the expectation of fighting in the wars to come, he would avoid them by continuing his lie about his gender. I believe it is justifiable because it made his life easier and it kept him out of situations that could put his life in danger. For example when he was in Pikesville, he would have been put in the pen, and have a higher chance of dying.
